Oreo Thanksgiving Dinner Cookie Tin Serves Up Six Bold Flavors, Dividing Fans

In a move that’s part culinary experiment and part social media spectacle, Oreo has released a Thanksgiving Dinner Cookie Tin, a limited-edition collection that reimagines classic holiday dishes as sandwich cookies. The lineup includes both beloved pies and eyebrow-raising savory options, sparking a fierce debate online between intrigued adventurers and horrified purists.

The OREOiD Thanksgiving Dinner Cookie Tin is available now for $19.99 exclusively on the OREO.com website, positioning the product as a bold “test-and-learn” flavor journey for dedicated fans .

The Six Flavors Inside the Tin

The limited-edition tin contains a full Thanksgiving feast in cookie form, with two cookies of each of the following six flavors :

Flavor	Category
Turkey & Stuffing	Savory Main
Creamed Corn	Savory Side
Sweet Potato	Sweet Side
Cranberry Sauce	Sweet Side
Caramel Apple Pie	Dessert
Pumpkin Pie	Dessert

The cookies themselves are described as being coated in a fudge that’s infused with the respective flavors, a detail that has particularly piqued curiosity about the savory varieties .

A Feast of Controversy: Fan Reactions Are Split

The announcement of these unconventional flavors has ignited a firestorm of reactions on social media, with comments ranging from disgusted to desperately curious.

• The Skeptics: Many users were quick to express their disbelief. One social media user simply stated, “No, I have no desire to try these,” while another reacted with “Turkey-flavored Oreos? 🤨🤢” . The sentiment of passing on the more savory flavors was common, with one person commenting, “Turkey and stuffing, and creamed corn? Ummm might pass on those 2 flavors” . Some, like Today.com, reported reviews as low as one out of five stars for the product .
• The Intrigued Adventurers: Despite the initial shock, many fans are drawn to the novelty. One perfectly captured the mixed feelings with the comment: “God this sounds disgusting. I wanna try them” . Others were more decisive in their excitement, with one fan writing, “Literally went and bought it as soon as I saw this post lmao” . Specific flavors like the Caramel Apple Pie were highlighted as sounding “🔥” .

The Real Sticking Point: Cost and Shipping

While the flavors are the main topic of debate, a significant point of contention for potential buyers has been the cost. The tin retails for $19.99, but it’s the shipping fees that have caused frustration .

Many customers have reported that standard shipping costs nearly double the total price, with some noting shipping charges as high as $24 on top of the $19.99 cost for the tin . TODAY.com observed that during a simulated checkout, shipping was discounted by 50%, but still came to $15.71 . This high barrier to entry has left some fans wishing the collectible tin was available in stores, but a company spokesperson confirmed it is an online exclusive .

More Than a Cookie: Oreo’s Flavor Experiment

Oreo is explicitly framing this release as an innovation test. The company describes it as a “test-and-learn” product that “invites fans to join a bold taste journey and share their honest feedback”. This isn’t just a quirky holiday product, it’s a market research initiative designed to gauge consumer reactions to extreme flavors and potentially “help shape the future of flavor innovation”.

This strategy follows a trend of unconventional Oreo releases, such as the recent Coca-Cola collaboration, and mirrors similar experimental moves in the food industry, like KFC’s plan to release fried chicken-flavored jelly beans .

The Oreo Thanksgiving Dinner Cookie Tin is more than a snack—it’s a conversation starter. Whether it’s seen as a genius marketing stunt or a culinary misstep, it has successfully captured the nation’s attention, proving that even a classic cookie brand can still surprise us.

---

FAQs….